Submission Guidelines

Symposium of Analytic Vignettes; Regular Submissions to Intégral Paused for Upcoming Volume (36)

The editors and staff of Intégral are pleased to announce a call for papers for a peer-reviewed symposium of analytical vignettes to be included in our upcoming volume (Volume 36). These vignettes are meant to be shorter submissions, between 2500 and 5000 words, and are typically narrower in scope. Analytical vignettes contribute original analytic ideas to specific works but do not necessarily have to develop new methodologies. We encourage submissions that address music by underrepresented composers and artists. Analytical vignettes will go through the same anonymous peer review process as articles. We will be accepting submissions for this symposium until September 1, 2022. Echoing the rise of lightning talks, SMT-Pod, and Indiana Theory Review’s similar call for shorter-form analytic essays, we feel that such a symposium aptly reflects some of the newer currents in our field and opens up a larger, more accessible, and more diverse space within the academic publishing ecosystem.

In tandem with this, however, we regretfully announce that we are pausing submissions for standard-format articles for Volume 36. The number of currently received submissions in various stages of review, along with the submissions we anticipate receiving for this symposium, has maxed out our graduate student staff’s ability to process these submissions in a timely manner. The earliest any new article submissions will be considered for publication will be Volume 37 (2024).

Format:

Submissions should be uploaded using the submission portal at the link below.

The portal will request contact information (author name and email address) for the submission, but this will remain separate from the submitted manuscript. Submission documents should not reveal the identity of the author and should be sent as a .doc, .docx, and/or .pdf file. All submissions should be sent with examples, figures, and tables included either in-line in the same document or as a separate PDF.

Citations should follow the author-date format for footnotes and bibliography from chapter 15 of the 17th edition of The Chicago Manual of Style. If a submission is accepted, authors will be expected to submit each figure as a separate image file (.tif, .jpg, .png, or .eps) of minimum 300 ppi. When applicable, videos should be submitted as .mp4 or .mov files. Alternatively, Intégral will gladly consider video example proposals in the form of storyboards or screenplays and may be able to offer advice on the composition of video examples. Securing permissions to reproduce copyrighted material is the responsibility of the author. Intégral strives to assist authors with formatting or typesetting musical examples and may request source files upon article acceptance.

Copyrights for materials published in Intégral are held by their authors. Materials may be disseminated on an individual basis for purposes of scholarly research, teaching, or discussion. Items appearing under our title may be saved and stored in electronic or paper form. However, work published in Intégral may not be republished in any form, electronic or print, without prior notification to the Co-Editors of this journal and without the express written consent of the author or authors.

Style:

See Intégral’s style sheet for guidance. For most grammatical and citation issues, see the Chicago Manual of Style, 17th edition.


Review:

Intégral practices double-anonymous peer review. Submissions are accepted through the online submission process. Co-Editors will initially review the submission to determine whether to disseminate it to outside reviewers and the staff. If the submission is deemed unsatisfactory or outside Intégral’s stated mandate (principally music theory, analysis, and criticism), Co-Editors will provide a response within 10 business days with appropriate feedback. If the submission is suitable for the journal, Co-Editors will share it with two members of the Editorial Board as well as the graduate student staff. Intégral takes three votes into account: the votes of each Editorial Board reviewer as well as the collective vote of the staff.

Authors should allow three months’ time for the process of peer review to be completed. The submission will ultimately yield one of the following three outcomes:

Accept with Revisions

The submission is well written, clearly argued, represents significant scholarship, and makes an original contribution to the field of music theory. The work will be published in Intégral without need for resubmission. Some revisions and corrections, potentially substantial in nature, will likely still be suggested by the Co-Editors, and acceptance is contingent upon authors adequately revising the paper in light of reviewer comments. Authors and Co-Editors will collaborate on the completion of such revisions and finalizing the text and examples.

Revise and Resubmit

The submission requires thorough rethinking, possibly due to organizational, factual, or stylistic inadequacies. Substantial rewriting and reframing will be necessary for resubmission, but resubmission is strongly encouraged. Authors asked to revise and resubmit are expected to compose a brief cover letter outlining how they have specifically addressed the reviewers’ concerns.

Reject

The submission falls outside of the journal’s purview or fails to meet the journal’s expectations of music theory scholarship. The submission will not be considered for publication in its current state.